Surat: A former office-bearer of the Southern Gujarat Chamber of Commerce & Industry (SGCCI) has sought clarification from the Manmade and Technical Textiles Export Promotion Council (MATEXIL) over the occupancy of a sixth-floor premises at the Surat International Exhibition and Convention Centre (SIECC), citing a 99-year lease granted in 2010 and raising questions about subsequent possession of the property.SGCCI patron member and former office-bearer Mitish Modi, a chartered accountant, has written to MATEXIL, a govt body, regarding the occupancy of the sixth floor of Building C, known as Sanhati Building, at the SIECC campus in Sarsana.In his letter, Modi stated that the Southern Gujarat Chamber Trade & Industry Development Centre, the lessor trust, entered into two leasehold rights agreements with the Synthetic & Rayon Textile Export Promotion Council (SRTEPC), now known as MATEXIL, in 2010. The agreements granted SRTEPC a 99-year lease of the sixth floor. The council paid an advance premium of Rs 2.06 crore to the trust.According to Modi, when Sanhati Building was completed in 2020, the sixth floor was handed over to SGCCI, which currently occupies the space.The agreement was signed by Rajendra Chokhawala on behalf of the lessor trust and by Narain Aggarwal, Surat office administrator of SRTEPC.Questioning the legality of the agreements, Modi wrote: “Rajendra Chokhawala was not a trustee on the public trust register (PTR) at the time of execution of both the lease hold Rights Agreements and even not on today. Thus, both the documents being executed and registered with the office of the Sub Registrar, Surat are illegal and not enforceable in the eyes of law since both the agreements are not signed by the trustees on PTR.”Modi stated that the premium paid by SRTEPC in 2010 is shown as a liability of Rs 2.34 crore in the audited report of the lessor trust.He also questioned how possession of the sixth floor could be handed to SGCCI in 2020 when the trust had entered into an agreement with SGCCI for the seventh and eighth floors in 2016. Modi further claimed that Chokhawala was the developer of the building before becoming a trustee.Sources said the issue surfaced after a recent SGCCI meeting where members discussed adding Sanhati Building as an additional address for the chamber.In his letter, Modi alleged breaches of revenue and charity commissioner rules. He sought clarification from MATEXIL regarding title and possession status, enforcement action, deed cancellation and audit disclosures.When contacted, Modi told TOI: “I have written letter in the interest of SGCCI. My intention is that both SGCCI and MATEXIL should not get into litigation and legal trouble in the future.”SGCCI president Ashok Jirawala declined to comment on the issue.
